After cleaning a church in Stockbridge, Massachusetts where they had Thanksgiving dinner the day before, Arlo Guthrie and a friend clean up the place, but toss the trash down a hill when they can’t find an open dump. They are arrested, fined $25 each, and forced to pick up the garbage. When they return to the church, Guthrie writes “Alice’s Restaurant Massacree” about the incident, embellishing some details.